Home Front Page AfricaLiberia: Attorney General Summoned Over IB Atlantic IV Release Order; Crew Still Held Past Deadline

Liberia: Attorney General Summoned Over IB Atlantic IV Release Order; Crew Still Held Past Deadline

Ministry of Justice In Contempt Trouble, As Court Summons AG Betty Lamin-Blamo Over Defiance Of Release Order
0:00 Listen to this article: --:-- min

MONROVIA – The Justice Ministry’s failure to obey a court order to release the vessel IB Atlantic IV and its seven crew members has turned into a direct confrontation with the judiciary.

Criminal Court “A” has summoned Justice Minister and Attorney General Cllr. Betty Lamin-Blamo to answer allegations of contempt.

Assigned Circuit Judge D. Onesimus Banwon issued a writ of summons ordering Lamin-Blamo to appear before the court at the Temple of Justice on Friday, Nov. 20, at 9 a.m. She must show cause why she should not be held in contempt for disobeying the court’s order to release the ship and its crew.

As of Thursday, when the writ was issued, the vessel and all seven crew members were still in state custody. The court’s deadline had passed at 4 p.m. Wednesday.

The summons puts the country’s chief legal officer before a judge to account for the government’s failure to obey a court order. It comes in a case that has dragged on for nearly three months without a full public explanation of what the vessel was doing or the legal grounds for holding it.

‘Show cause’

The writ, dated Nov. 19 and issued under the authority of the First Judicial Circuit, Montserrado County, is explicit. It orders the attorney general to explain why she should not be held in contempt for disobeying the release order.

Assistant Clerk of Court Gideon A. Eshun issued the summons to Montserrado County Sheriff H. C. Sulonich or his deputy for service. The court told the sheriff to report back to the clerk’s office on how the summons was served.

The writ is not a finding of contempt. But it is a serious step. It requires the government’s top lawyer to answer personally for her ministry’s failure to comply.

It also raises a larger question: Can the government keep people and property in custody after a court has ordered their release, without going back to the court for permission?

Deadline passes, crew stays put

Judge Banwon had ordered the release of the IB Atlantic IV and its crew after their lawyers filed a habeas corpus petition challenging their detention. The ministry was given until 4 p.m. Wednesday to comply.

It did not. At about 5 p.m. Wednesday, FrontPageAfrica observed that the order had not been carried out. Lawyers for the seven crew members confirmed their clients were still being held.

By Thursday, nothing had changed. That left the court to take the extra step of summoning the attorney general.

Reached late Wednesday and asked why the release had not happened, Solicitor General Cllr. Abrahim Sillah gave no explanation.

“I will refer you to find out from the court, my brother,” Sillah told FrontPageAfrica.

His answer left the central question unaddressed: On what legal basis is the government still holding the ship and its crew after the court’s deadline expired?

Ministry ‘struggling’ for an explanation

Sources at the Justice Ministry, who spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss the matter, told FrontPageAfrica earlier that the ministry was struggling to come up with an explanation for the continued detention.

Part of the difficulty, the sources said, was the government’s own earlier public statements that it was investigating the vessel’s movements and how it came to be intercepted. No findings from that investigation have been made public. That left officials hard-pressed to justify holding the ship and crew in the face of a court order.

The sources said the ministry was considering releasing the vessel and crew early Thursday to comply with the order. That did not happen.

Lamin-Blamo is now expected to explain in court why the order was not obeyed on time, and to present whatever legal justification the government has for keeping the ship and crew in custody.

The ship that slipped away

The IB Atlantic IV is a 41-year-old, Comoros-flagged general cargo ship. It first drew attention this summer when it lingered off York Island in Tewor District, Grand Cape Mount County, alarming residents and fishermen.

Before that, the ship had already tried to get into Liberia. On July 13, a Liberian businessman, Kuiah, wrote to the Liberia Maritime Authority (LiMA) on behalf of a company called Madris Group of Companies Inc. He asked for docking rights and a dive team at the Freeport of Monrovia, describing the vessel as disabled and “in distress.” FrontPageAfrica later reported that Kuiah, a former deputy at Roberts International Airport who was dismissed, was the company’s sole owner. LiMA turned the request down. The ship was still in Sierra Leonean waters at the time and had not docked anywhere, yet it was already seeking a Liberian berth.

Once the vessel drifted onto the Liberian side of the maritime border, the order came to search and seize it. It kept moving. On Aug. 4, then-Armed Forces of Liberia Chief of Staff Maj. Gen. Davidson Forleh confirmed that security forces were in pursuit. He told FrontPageAfrica that the Coast Guard’s boats were not equipped to chase a ship far out to sea. With Nigerian help, the military tracked it off Rivercess County but could not board it.

Investigators also looked into reports that a smaller vessel had approached the IB Atlantic IV and tried to throw something aboard. The government said a Liberian fishing vessel had gone out to meet the ship, and the National Fisheries and Aquaculture Authority opened an inquiry.

The ship was finally seized by Ivorian authorities on Aug. 9. On Aug. 14, Information Minister Jerolinmek M. Piah confirmed the arrest and said Liberia was working with Côte d’Ivoire to bring it back. It returned under Liberian Coast Guard command on Aug. 27.

The chase unfolded amid a widening national drug-trafficking scandal, and speculation about contraband aboard ran high. But authorities have never publicly established that any narcotics were found on the vessel.

Its return was supposed to give the government a chance to investigate and give the public a full account. Instead, the ship and crew stayed in custody for nearly three months with no findings released. That drove the vessel’s management and crew to court.

Friday’s test

For the seven crew members, the case has meant months of uncertainty, held aboard a ship whose presence in Liberian waters is still unexplained.

The government is now being asked to answer for more than the vessel. It must also explain why it kept the ship and its crew in custody after a judge ordered them freed.

That answer is due Friday at 9 a.m., when Lamin-Blamo is expected to appear before Criminal Court “A” at the Temple of Justice.

Follow Liberia News Network on Google

See more Liberia News Network stories in Google Search by adding LNN as one of your Preferred Sources.

★ Add LNN as a Preferred Source